На днях была интересная вещь: некий автор написал на VC текст с анализом статистики активности пользователей ВКонтакте за последние несколько лет. В нём он неправильным способом пришёл к правильному выводу: активность людей снижается. Способ неправильный, потому что сразу было видно, что сравниваются между собой разные показатели в разные моменты времени (а нужно сравнивать один и тот же показатель в разные моменты времени).
Тем не менее, статья вызвала широчайший резонанс (62 тысячи просмотров, более 500 комментариев, по мерках VC это очень много).
ВКонтакте сначала ответили в комментариях чем-то в духе: "Нас уже 10 лет хоронят, а мы ещё живы". А затем опубликовали материал от имени аж CEO, где привели вроде бы много цифр и графиков, но все они в основном сводились к единственному показателю из разных источников: суммарная месячная аудитория. И из графика под этим постом видно, что рост MAU, которым ВК так хвастается, замедлился как раз тогда, когда все люди пришли в интернет из-за пандемии -- второй квартал 2020.
В комментариях, ожидаемо, многие пишут, что их личные наблюдения не соответствуют рассказанному в статье. Но дьявол тут именно в этом показателе: он ничего не показывает. А люди наблюдают падение активности, а не падение чисел для отчётов. На какие показатели действительно хотелось бы посмотреть:
- средний возраст активной аудитории,
- конверсия просмотров в лайки и комментарии,
- средняя длина текста в публикации,
- доля публикаций без внешних ссылок,
- отношение активных подписчиков на личных страницах и в сообществах к общему количеству подписчиков
- процент удалённых аккаунтов
Именно в динамике посмотреть, как эти данные менялись от месяца к месяцу. И тогда уже сделать выводы. Потому что фраза "ВК умирает" не означает, что содержимое по адресу vk com перестаёт существовать. Если администрация превратит эту соцсеть в догоняющий клон тиктока, то аудитория будет. Просто не будет от ВК ничего, кроме названия.
Ну и самое крутое: один из комментаторов обратил внимание на значимое явление. Генеральный директор ВК пришла писать длинную статью про ВК на другой ресурс. Потому что у самого ВК уже нет возможности показать длинный текст на большую аудиторию.
#web
⚡️PRO THUNDER V12: THE ELITE TRADING STANDARD⚡️
Stop settling for repainting tools and local scripts. Pro Thunder V12 is the culmination of 5 years of development by SS7Trader Ltd.
Why the pros choose V12:
🚫100% Non-Repaint: Signals are fixed. What you see is what you get.
🧠Neural Network AI: Powered by advanced AI to filter market noise.
✅Registered Authority: Built by a verified company, not an anonymous team.
⏳5-Year Legacy: Continuous evolution and optimization since 2021.
🎯 Pure Simplicity: Clear Buy/Sell signals with a fixed 5-minute expiry.
🌍 Universal: Works on any broker, any chart, and any timeframe.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🚀 JOIN THE ELITE. STOP GUESSING.
🔗https://ss7trader.com/product/pro-thunder-v12/
✈️ Contact: https://t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingAI#NonRepaint#BinaryOptions
⚡️PRO THUNDER V12: THE ELITE TRADING STANDARD⚡️
Stop settling for repainting tools and local scripts. Pro Thunder V12 is the culmination of 5 years of development by SS7Trader Ltd.
Why the pros choose V12:
🚫100% Non-Repaint: Signals are fixed. What you see is what you get.
🧠Neural Network AI: Powered by advanced AI to filter market noise.
✅Registered Authority: Built by a verified company, not an anonymous team.
⏳5-Year Legacy: Continuous evolution and optimization since 2021.
🎯 Pure Simplicity: Clear Buy/Sell signals with a fixed 5-minute expiry.
🌍 Universal: Works on any broker, any chart, and any timeframe.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🚀 JOIN THE ELITE. STOP GUESSING.
🔗https://ss7trader.com/product/pro-thunder-v12/
✈️ Contact: https://t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingAI#NonRepaint#BinaryOptions
⚡️PRO THUNDER V12: THE ELITE TRADING STANDARD⚡️
Stop settling for repainting tools and local scripts. Pro Thunder V12 is the culmination of 5 years of development by SS7Trader Ltd.
Why the pros choose V12:
🚫100% Non-Repaint: Signals are fixed. What you see is what you get.
🧠Neural Network AI: Powered by advanced AI to filter market noise.
✅Registered Authority: Built by a verified company, not an anonymous team.
⏳5-Year Legacy: Continuous evolution and optimization since 2021.
🎯 Pure Simplicity: Clear Buy/Sell signals with a fixed 5-minute expiry.
🌍 Universal: Works on any broker, any chart, and any timeframe.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🚀 JOIN THE ELITE. STOP GUESSING.
🔗https://ss7trader.com/product/pro-thunder-v12/
✈️ Contact: https://t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingAI#NonRepaint#BinaryOptions
⚡️PRO THUNDER V12: THE ELITE TRADING STANDARD⚡️
Stop settling for repainting tools and local scripts. Pro Thunder V12 is the culmination of 5 years of development by SS7Trader Ltd.
Why the pros choose V12:
🚫100% Non-Repaint: Signals are fixed. What you see is what you get.
🧠Neural Network AI: Powered by advanced AI to filter market noise.
✅Registered Authority: Built by a verified company, not an anonymous team.
⏳5-Year Legacy: Continuous evolution and optimization since 2021.
🎯 Pure Simplicity: Clear Buy/Sell signals with a fixed 5-minute expiry.
🌍 Universal: Works on any broker, any chart, and any timeframe.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🚀 JOIN THE ELITE. STOP GUESSING.
🔗https://ss7trader.com/product/pro-thunder-v12/
✈️ Contact: https://t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingAI#NonRepaint#BinaryOptions
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
👑Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️ Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
👑Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️ Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
👑Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️ Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
⚙Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
⚙Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
⚙Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
⚙Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading
Pro Thunder V12: The Ultimate Trading Solution!
The wait is over! Pro Thunder V12 is finally here to revolutionize your trading. It's time to trade smarter with V12 Intelligence and leave the emotions behind.
⚙Featuring Four New Layers of Intelligence In Pro Thunder V12 Version:
⭐️Neural Engine
⭐️Neural Channel
⭐️Live News Panel
⭐️Neural Networks 2.0 (Upgraded)
👑 Key Features:
👉 100% Non-Repaint: Trustworthy signals that never disappear.
👉 85%+ Win Rate: High accuracy for consistent results.
👉Zero Martingale: A safer approach to trading.
👉Verified Back Testing Results: Proven performance you can rely on.
👉Telegram Alerts: Get notified instantly on your phone.
👉5-Minutes Expiry: Optimized for quick trades.
Backed by 10 Years of Expertise and Thousands of Success Stories.
👉Get Your Copy Now
⭐️
🔗Buy Link:https://ss7trader.com
✈️Telegram: t.me/SSsevenTrader
#SS7Trader#ProThunderV12#TradingIndicator#Forex#BinaryOptions#NonRepaint#TradingSignals#SmartTrading